Summary indexing and multiple transforming commands

[JacobPN]

Hi all,

I have a search that runs over eventdata from a website that runs over a few weeks of data. It should return (among other things) the average number of pageviews per user and the standard deviation of this number. I want to create a summary index of this data. I am using two transforming commands to achieve this. The final one of these I replace by its si- variant to create the summary index. However, the results are not the same as when I just run the original search (over the same time range) against the raw data.

The search looks like this:

event="pageview"
| rename ...
| eval Variant = ... , deviceGroup = ...
| stats count as pageview_per_user by userID, Variant, deviceGroup
| sistats dc(userID) as users, sum(pageview_per_user) as pageviews, avg(pageview_per_user) as avg_pv, stdev(pageview_per_user) as std_pv by Variant, deviceGroup
In particular the total number of pageviews is way off when I use the summary index. I am running the search that populates the summary index over a time range: 1 august until -1h@h. It runs every hour.

What could be the problem here, could it be the use the two (si)stats commands?

By the way, I realize I could probably use report acceleration here, but I want to understand summary indexing better.

Best, Jacob

[DalJeanis]

There is nothing wrong with two stats commands, as long as they are aggregating the information you want them to collect. Since the aggregation is running hourly, across a longer time frame, you need to add _time into the first stats in order to collect valid comparison data.

Do this across your longer time frame and see how well it matches a pull from your summary for the same time frame.

  event="pageview"
 | rename ...
 | eval Variant = ... , deviceGroup = ...
 | bin _time span=1h
 | stats count as pageview_per_user by userID, Variant, deviceGroup, _time
 | stats count as users, sum(pageview_per_user) as pageviews, avg(pageview_per_user) as avg_pv, stdev(pageview_per_user) as std_pv by Variant, deviceGroup

or

 | sistats dc(userID) as users, sum(pageview_per_user) as pageviews, avg(pageview_per_user) as avg_pv, stdev(pageview_per_user) as std_pv by Variant, deviceGroup

[adonio]

looks like you are doing stats over stats.
try and arrange the data according to your needs and use the | collect command to send the results to summary index.
read here more:
http://docs.splunk.com/Documentation/SplunkCloud/6.6.0/SearchReference/Collect

[JacobPN]

Thanks! Could you explain a little about why the stats over stats search I wrote gives the wrong results?

And should I just replace sistats by stats, pipe everything to collect, and schedule the search to run every hour (and should I still check "Enable" under summary indexing when I save the serach?).
Sorry for my ignorance.